Should You buy an Above-Ground or an In-Ground Pool?

Trying to decide between an above ground vs. inground pool? The choice depends on your budget, installation process, maintenance costs, and long-term value. Above ground pools are more affordable and easier to install, while inground pools add property value and offer a longer lifespan. With plenty of choices on the market, we've laid the groundwork to help you decide which pool type will work for you and the space.

Above Ground Pools: Cost, Installation & Maintenance

Above ground pool is a pool structure that sits on top of the ground. Depending on whether you are seeking a temporary or permanent installation, there are a couple of options, sizes and price points for an above ground pool. Consequently, the visual appearance of an above ground pool can vary based on these factors.

The Cost of Inflatable Pools

Referring to your inflatable pool as an above ground pool may sound impressive in social gatherings, but it may not necessarily enhance your property value. Inflatable pools are easily accessed at various retailers such as Kmart or Bunnings, with prices ranging from $50 to $2,000. They serve as a practical option for those living in rental properties or seeking a temporary solution. However, if you're searching for a more permanent and value-adding feature for your home, you should consider other types of pools.

The Cost of Above Ground Vinyl Pools

One of the best pool options on a budget is the vinyl above ground pool, which can be installed by a pool professional for a starting price of $10,000. It's worth noting that, as with any product subject to natural wear and tear, it may require replacement after 6-12 years of use. The cost for such replacement ranges between $3,000 and $4,000, which is a crucial consideration when factoring in the long-term costs associated with this type of pool.

The Cost of Above Ground Modular Pools

Modular pools, which are pre-manufactured and self-sustaining, are available in various shapes and sizes. Container shipping pools and plunge pools are among the examples that fall under this category, and the cost can range from $20,000 to $40,000. Modular pools are engineered to be a "plug and play" pool, allowing for swift installation. Furthermore, depending on the chosen material, upkeep for modular pools is typically lower than for vinyl pools.

The Cost of Above Ground Fibreglass Pools

As a pool owner, it's essential to consider the type of pool that best suits your preferences and needs. While Fibreglass pools are typically installed fully within the ground, achieving an above ground fibreglass pool is possible if desired. However, extensive earthworks and retaining walls must be constructed to ensure the pool is level with the ground, creating an inground effect.
The cost of earthworks can vary depending on the extent of the work needed, with prices ranging up to $30,000 or more to transform your backyard into a suitable space for your pool. It's important to note that this cost does not include the price of the pool itself, which can vary significantly based on factors such as shape, size, features, and landscaping options. Pool prices can range from $25,000 to over $70,000, so it's crucial to consider all aspects when deciding.

Above Ground Pool Costs & Factors to Consider Before Buying

1. Pool Fencing costs:

According to Australian law, pool fencing must adhere to local government standards. The cost of pool fencing varies depending on the style of fencing. A standard aluminium powder-coated fence starts at $100 per meter.

2. Landscaping:

The cost of landscaping depends on the desired design of your backyard oasis. The budget for landscaping can vary from modest to extravagant, depending on your preferences and financial capabilities.

3. Water Filtration:

Investing in a reliable water filtration system is crucial in maintaining a clean and healthy pool, especially when you're not around. Consider products like Titan Series Thermoplastic Sand Pool Filter or CV Cartridge Filters for optimum water filtration performance.

Types of In-Ground Pool

Three different types of in-ground pools are sold in the Australian market, which includes concrete, fibreglass, and vinyl pools. Depending on the pool's style and size, the initial costs and ongoing maintenance of each type of pool can vary.

Pros and Cons of Concrete Pools

Concrete pools offer a wide range of design choices in terms of size and shape, which can make pricing estimation challenging. Moreover, the construction time for a concrete pool can be prolonged, and weather conditions can be a huge factor, potentially dragging on the building process for several months.

Concrete surfaces also can be prone to porosity, which may require continuous attention to prevent the onset of algae and bacteria. Resurfacing may be required every 15 years to maintain its optimal condition, which adds to the overall long-term maintenance cost.

Pros and Cons of Fibreglass Pools

Fibreglass pools offer a diverse range of sizes, shapes, and features, with prices ranging from $25,000 to $50,000 or more depending on the chosen specifications and installation requirements.

Fibreglass pools also require a shorter installation time when compared to concrete pools, as the pool structure is pre-manufactured off-site and then installed once the excavation is done. Fibreglass pools also offer a smoother and non-porous surface, which makes maintenance relatively easy as it is difficult for algae to grow on the pool's surface. This, coupled with a salt chlorinator, will have your pool ready for summer in no time!

Pros and Cons of Vinyl Pools

In-ground vinyl pools, while not as commonly chosen as their counterparts, are available at a similar price point to fibreglass pools. However, the vinyl pools may require more maintenance in the long run as the pool linings typically have a lifespan of up to 10 years and may require replacement depending on the level of upkeep.

The cost of relining an average-sized pool could exceed $4,000, adding to the long-term expenses of owning a vinyl pool. Therefore, while initially priced comparably to fibreglass pools, potential pool owners should take into account the cost of upkeep and replacement when considering vinyl pools as an option.

Above Ground vs. In-Ground Pools Comparison

Bottom Line

In-ground pools typically entail an initial cost of up to $70,000, and they can last a lifetime if properly installed and equipped with suitable pool pumps, heaters, and filters. Additionally, in-ground pools can increase the overall property value for potential buyers. Alternatively, above ground pools are easy to install but have a shorter lifespan, which means that you may need to reinvest in the pool every 7-12 years, adding to the long term costs.

When deciding on the appropriate pool for your home, it's essential to think about the duration of your ownership and the purpose of the pool. This will also help in determining whether to invest in a pool with a higher initial cost but a longer lifespan or opt for an affordable pool now that may require replacement later.

If you are still uncertain about which pool is ideal for your property, consider consulting your local pool dealer for expert advice.